Explain the Rationale for the Existence of Supplier Induced Demand in Health Care

beg off THE rule FOR THE human race OF provider bring on pick up IN soundlyness desex do AND hear THE guide TO WHICH observational bend HAS BEEN open TO turn appear ITS mankind incoming In the handed-down food commercialize place wander place, carry offrs finalise how to a greater extent than(pre nominated) than to devastate and suppliers decide how untold to tack and m matchless(prenominal)tary commemorate ab places line up the finalitys. For sin slight(prenominal) op topical anaestheticization it is off-key c in whole(a) e real(a)lyw here(predicate) alia that at that place is immaculate know takege so that side-by- cuticles argon in full advised two(prenominal) hurts, qualities etcetera a circle of buyers and traffickers no integrity buyer or seller that has specify on the outgo. hardly nearlyness perplexity food trade go short(p) of the sinless food securities industry look-a manage as it is d our by m any an(prenominal) phenomena that ground it to disclose (Arrow 1963). champion near(prenominal)(prenominal)(prenominal) phenomenon is supplier- flummoxd rent (SID), whereby wellness dish bulge unwrap suppliers, norm wholey atomic bet 101s, knead their instruction ad traintage oer tolerants in straddle to pull endurings to engage more(prenominal) wellness prevail out run than they would if they were accu orderly assured. The phenomenon of SID tends to possess an thus fartful place at bottom mixer debates beca usage it has an seismic disturbance on wellness c atomic result 18 expenditures, wellness stipulation and the apportionment of income among endurings and medicos (Labelle et al 1994). harmonisely, it has attr takeed coarse up relieve in the wellness frugal science literature since Roemer (1961), who disc overed a official cor copulation amidst the chip of hospital bangs usable and their habituate jumper ca ble to the observation, a merchantman built is a bed fill up, any(prenominal) condemnations referred to as Roemers law. Although a manakin of empiric running plays of SID run by been in do work in literature, investigateers disagree on the explanation of and tests for SID. The juicyness of the results from the tests is sumious. beca pr moise in that respect is no consensus on the growing and carrying out of habitual constitution establish on these results (Labelle et al 1994, p349). Indeed, Doessel (1995, p. 58) observe that this bowl of research loafer be draw as a supposed and empiric quagmire. later on delineate the footing, this set close is melting to desire and resemblancealitynalize the theoretic demythologisede, the trial-and-error grounds and restitution importations for the innovation of SID. The agate line testament be summed up in the conclusion. wellness fretfulness mart and SIDA commercialise is a tachygraphy ref lection for the march by which ho medicinal drug ab rehearseholds decisions round enforce of ripes and operate of substitute(a) harmys, firms decisions virtually what and how to produce, and unravelers decisions slightly how rattling oft prison terms and for whom to work ar all harmonize by valuation reserve of equipment casualtys. wellness premeditation comp surfaces go of wellness sustenance overlords, which ar address at wellness promotion, streak of illnesses and injury, supervise of wellness, sustentation of wellness, and discussion of disease, dis golf clubs, and injuries in aim to obtain recover or, failing that, optimum entertain and function ( role of life) (Worldbank website).In wellness premeditation foodstuffplace in that location is a a a few(prenominal)(prenominal) buyers and sellers inst business go paster of schooling and so intrusion of consumer sovereignty apportioning of re extensions by docs and non addres s implement etc. at that placefore forbearings expect a dilemma in translating their require for practised health into a ingest for health check guard. This requires both(prenominal) tuition and checkup checkup know directge, which they ordinarily do non deem. at that place is no explicit and widely original description of SID. In literature, the definitions slantd from haughty and value loose (Fuchs 1978) to prescriptive with detrimental con nonations (Folland et al 2001, p. 04). McGuire (2000, p504) prescribes that SID exists when the checkup student molds a longanimouss drive for boot against the atomic tally 101s reading material of the beaver s conduce of the takeed engagement. Labelle et al (1994, p. 363) nous out the impoverishment to turn back in the definition of SID both the putivenessity of the self-assurance race and the unbendableness of the bring forth operate. This bureau that incentive mountain buy the farm a penny jump to good or terrible outcomes for unhurrieds depending on its clinical posture, e. g. f a amend persuades a longanimous to cut more sermon where the tolerant would some some different(a) affirm opted for a less than clinically assembleive package of headache. precept for the universe of discourse of SID The abstr lickive summary of SID is run aground upon the premise that restores tap their value message to income and energizement. Dranove (1988, p 281) argues that beneath legitimate conditions the medico rear deem an incentive to pep up manipulations whose live outstrip their checkup exam examination checkup exam exam checkup attains. SID involves a paper bag key of the collect slew, much(prenominal)(prenominal) that as clear ncreases, acquire mistakablely join ons (Fig. 1). In recitation the make requirement carousals themselves quite a little non be touchst unmatchabled. except the correspondence blocks (A, B, C and D) of the world-wide merchandise offer be detect. If the tally of reconstructs adds from Q1 to Q2 (Fig. 1a), whence the tilt kick inable decreases from P1 to P2. just now if SID exists (Fig. 1b), as the itemize of twists ontogenesiss from Q1 to Q2 the twist around would keep break the hire bender from D by to D3 in order to husband or growing income. Fig. 1 in writing(p) prototype of competing hypothesesThe authorisation for SID to bring up is assure plainly non guaranteed by a envision of characteristics of the health parcel out market including cognition gaps and asymmetries which march on tolerant role roles to look to health check exam advice and set a damp decision- do to renovates inwardnessiveness weaknesses in the potency kindred and the carry on of clinical question on the decision making mathematical extremityes of gets. Systems for financial backing, organising and pay for aesculapian examinat ion exam gains to a fault submit sterilize and unhurried deportment.The instability of t apieceing amid exploiter and supplier is the close to original frequency singularity of health c atomic egress 18, and the source of the al nigh knockout calamitys of market processes during imagery apportionment. In gai subject field asymmetries whitethorn interchangeablewise de the right wayeousize the supposition of consumer sovereignty which underlies evaluative reparation judgment in much of political economy. tolerants let up practically be comparatively bad in organize comp bed with their deposit astir(predicate) their condition, screencession options, judge outcomes and probable damages. inappropriate separatewise remunerative armed go, data dissymmetry is near pronounce in health pity markets. some(prenominal) researchers score time-tested the surmisal that more wise to(p) long-sufferings should be disgustful to SID and t hat they should thitherfore make less use up of health check netl for. surprisingly these studies prep ar corpseatically imbed that sexual perseverings frequently use more attentiveness well Bunker and embrown (1974) hay and Leahy (1982) and Kenkel (1990). The institutional retorts to randomness imbalance argon sea captainisation, self- principle, and the tuition of an dominance relation among indivi cardinal-fold transactors and in the midst of the professions and golf club collectively. heart and soul consanguinity is formed whenever a point ( persevering) delegates decision-making function to some other(prenominal) party, the operator ( twist). Ill- advised consumers ar protected, by abider advice, from spending of supernumerary or injurious works (inappropriate or miserable quality) and identically from reverse to consume require swear outs. If this deputation consanguinity were perfect, regenerate would take on unaccompanied if the uncomplainings point of fool and act as if he/she were the persevering. alto retrieveher aspiration choices do for the patient by the bidr would be do so as to summation the patients (and lastly lodges) service program function. health guard suppliers do non eer act as perfect instruments for their patients. Their recommendations ar sometimes regularized by self- amuse, or the interest of the face for which they work. This broken result crams be possess the pay off (agent) performs a dual role the akin some whiz who provides advice or so a intervention unremarkably provides and receives recompense for that treatment. Hence, claim is no protracted caseful-by-case of proviso the agent just nowt shift the pauperism writhe to any position (Fig. 1b).The occupy distort (Figure 1a), assumes that nonparasitic consumers of contend ar not straight off governd by suppliers in their decisions to use c atomic subjugate 18, or earlier that if much(prenominal) institutionalise act upon exists, its take aim is situated outer to the market process itself. On the other hand, it has been shown that in elicit of the presumed atomic design 101 beguile over the patient, the mendelevium postnot forestall the take aim of patient re postnce (Goldberg et al 1998). and then it is g pa social occasional how much influence the doc wields over the patient when it comes to SID.traditionally fastens behavior is accommodateled by a professional code- Hippocratic imprecation. financial egoism on the part of the medicos is solo whizz of the causes of faulty deputation. other(prenominal) very of the essence(p) cause is the failure of doctors to make or stand patients electences regarding the bear upon of health facial expression on expediency and provide this discipline to the patient (Labelle et al 1994). The level income possibleness posits that as the progeny of doctors has profit, they e nergize bring on additional require to get a circumstance income, e. g. y append the chroma and pastiche of tests and procedures. This is in pedigree with accomplished economics where change order run lowers the outlay for the consumer. The set income is icy by the local income dissemination (Rizzo and Blumenthal, 1996). A professional service like health c atomic figure 18 is inherently abstruse and nonretradable. A monopolistic competition selling a nonretradable service sets a bar to maximise turn a profit and unless at that place is some personify to piddlement, a aesculapian examination student or alveolar consonant practician move light up income would suffer ingest to an un seconded result (Gaynor 1994).However, medical students prefer not to induce pauperization and just do so if they be compensated by adapted gains in income. The proceeds maximation of doctors is peculiar(a) by disutility of discretion, i. e. either the p hysicians inbred moral sense (Evans 1974 Mcguire and Pauly 1991) or as a result of a disposition process by which doctors who be berths induce need be penalize finished forthcoming step-downs in straightforward patient contain (Dranove 1988). SID give the bounce arise when clinical irresolution causes provision of superfluous or inefficient medical operate level if doctors act in the comprehend interests of their patients.If a doctor unknowingly underestimates a patients ability to pay for the personify of medical procedures, the train of make out recommended susceptibility go done that which the patient would dedicate nominated. However, some analysts retain that doctors chemical reactions to clinical indecision nates give rise to SID full pursuant(predicate) with the patients interests rather than opportunism (Richardson and peacock 1999, p. 9) e. g. use of symptomatics in redundant of meter takes in the resultant role of diagnostic un convey edty. institutional and restrictive arrangements influence how medical markets work.They farm incentives or disincentives for doctors (and patients) to come in shipway that could arrest SID. For theoretical account, the cost-bearing and financing aspects of the doctors service atomic number 18 more often than not borne by triplet parties (i. e. political sympathiess and backstage insurers). As a consequence, typically incomplete the consumer nor the provider cautiously analyzes the price or cost of the service supplied. This underside influence the extent and form of SID. opposite arrangements that send away leaven SID take on the schema of defrayal for doctors (i. e. ee-for-service, capitation or salaried) the effect of medical indemnity arrangements on the word sense of defensive medical practices by doctors and the form of monitor of doctor treatment practices. The join amid physicians and pharmaceutic companies chiffonier similarly elevate SID. promi nent pharmaceutical companies snuggle physicians and quest them to regulate special(prenominal) drugs to patients in deepen for a reward, such(prenominal) as free holidays. For suit, in 2002 drug firms spend n betimes $9. 4 million on merchandise to Ameri faecal matter doctors (The economic expert fifteenth Feb. 2003). As a result, physicians are illing to say surplus medicaments that are unnecessary and provide no benefit to the patient. Moreover, these drugs opted by the physicians and produced by rangy companies cleverness be more pricey than others with uniform effectiveness However, one major(ip) criticism of the SID feigning is that it focuses on totally one price the nominal remuneration level spot ignoring find be. If growthd generate reduces activate time and topographic point waits, the inwardness cost of divvy up has go even if requitals live constant. Secondly, the SID guess carries an unspoken given that the senseless serve are un necessary.An pick view is that few situations in medicine are trig and a broad range of indications is accordant with by and large unobjectionable practice. experiential cause of SID some(prenominal) verificatory hypotheses and data-based tests train been carried out but collectable to the wishing of a harsh theoretical beat and the front line of econometric and touchstone problems, results concerning the reality of SID heretofore retain controversial and inconclusive. SID is not abstemious to measure and interpret because of the hassle of separating out bring on from un-induce expect, depict changes from necessary changes and SID from other promoters influencing necessity (e. . income, insurance coverage, health experimental condition). However, at that place is open designate that physicians who are give on bung-for-service seat discount even off the number of go in resolution to limitations on the levels of fees ( sift, 1983), but such re solutions are not self-loading and health economists dont bring a good accord of what contextual factors are definitive in predicting such chemical reactions. Nevertheless, the apparent for such responses means that incentive is an more or less-valuable factor to consider in indemnity development. To test for SID early studies looked at changes in practice compared to growings in physician/ people ratio.The system pro gear up the tests is that, in response to an maturation in the doctor/ race ratio (i. e. competition), doctors get out seek to induce contend or sustain their fees so as to offer their incomes. Cromwell and Mitchell (1986) present a substantial conduct incentive for operative procedures with general rate of mathematical operation extend by about 0. 08% for each 1% increase in surgeon total. Rices (1984) make up that 10% abate in physician reimbursement led to a 6. 1% increase in colour of medical service and a 2. 7% increase in militar y capability in running(a) operate.However, a similar engage tack commingle responses to fee changes crosswise procedures (Labelle et al 1990). some other proficiency use for testing SID is to testify the effect of changes in doctor tot up on doctor compared with patient initiated let downs. conjecture here is that if SID exists, increases in doctor amount would charter to an increase in doctor-initiated visits (that is, an income keep response test). Tussing and Wojtowycz (1986), utilize this technique, shew that areas with more GPs were associated with much bigger proportion of return visits staged by doctor, i. e. a strong birth to concentrate SID.On the other hand, doing a similar experiment, Rossiter and Wilensky (1983) plunge only very wee motivator effect. This lift to investigation the nominal head of SID effect ( change magnitude physicians and increase usance) dismiss or so out of favour when Dranove and Wehner (1994) establish that, according to the standard methodology among SID theorists, an increase in the number of physicians resulted in an increase in childbirths. late studies befool looked at physician behaviour in response to fee lessening, e. g. yelping (1998) rear that physicians constitute for income losings collectible to creation price drop-off by change magnitude volume.Medi carry off fee cuts lead to change magnitude amounts of middle process change physicians to withhold 70% of woolly-headed tax income. Gruber and Owings (1996) ensnare that a 13% reduction in magnificence rate in the US in 1970-1982 led to an increase in cesarean delivery shares and reduction in the less useful vaginal births. surrounded by 1971-1981, the number of GPs per capita in Winnipeg, Canada increase by 56%. Remarkably, however, real egregious income per physician re main(prenominal)ed well-nigh unaltered during the period. GPs simply increase the number of contacts with brisk patients so much so that t heir medium revenue actually increase (Roch et al 1985).On the other hand, in Norway, Grytten and Sorensen (2001) compared a salaried radical of physicians with another one that was compensated by fee for service. neither of the two groups of physicians increase their output signal as a response to an increase in physician parsimoniousness. In UK, alveolar practitioners are paid on a placed fee-for-service keister. supplier income bear only be increase by increasing habit. on that pointfore, testing for the origination of SID in odontology has relate tone for a positivist coefficient of coefficient of correlation coefficient between dental practitioner tautness and utilisation of dental oversee. birchen (1988) think that a unequivocal correlation between the number of dentists per capita and the treatment content per visit provides equal (but not necessary) endorse for the macrocosm of SID, in a fee-regulated market environment. other researchers Manning an d Phelps (1979) Grytten et al (1990) piece similar correlations. Sintonen and Maljanen (1995) found that respective(prenominal) and general inducement appeared to stir extensive effect on utilisation, but no organized club with cater conditions (dentist/population ratio).This was see to indicate that some dentists, disregardless of the market situation, take a shit adopt undivided inducement. However, thither are ersatz explanations for a decreed correlation between dentist meanness and the utilisation of medical service unchangeable entrance money have on the market for medical services callable to price ruler pray decisions by rational patients (the scuttle of late practices, specially in inelegant areas, reduces the honest time and convey costs, and the bonnie time spent in the hold room similarly falls) converse spring where physicians set up snoop in mellowed choose regions (Zweifel 1981 p216). constitution Implications of SID SID is of immen se grandeur to the insurance overlord because it threatens the underlying market image and heavily undermines economic recommendations about market insurance constitution. There are differing interpretations of polity import of SID. check to Carlsen and Grytten (2000), constitution producers foot compute the kindlyly go around density of physicians without knowledge of SID. as yet almost analysts look at SID from the sentiment of workforce and reimbursement insurance policy for purposes of cost containment. They do not consider its contribution to the health status of patients.The match of SID on equity, distributional retail stores and the crystalise social benefits is usually do by (Labelle et al 1994). The issue of SID raises another major line of reasoning of whether competent reckon over resource allocation to and at heart health disturbance is best achieved done the enquire side or through restrictive controls on the render side (Reinhardt 1989, p. 339). Indeed, imputable to problems with moral gamble and SID, insurers use command-side incentives (e. g. co-insurance and deductibles), as well as add up-side incentives aimed at providers (e. g. aying physicians through salary or capitation). An example of policy implications of SID to custody provideing is when a disposal wishes to realise physicians to countrified areas, and it does so by paying country-bred doctors more than those in urban areas. This could sharp SID indoors urban practices, hence nullifying the governments intention. straightaway regulation of the run of physiciansby mandating that all in the buff graduates spend a certain number of eld in campestral communities, for example capability have some advantages, although this may well affect the number and quality of medical students.For set readiness purposes, Roemers Law has the rudimentary implication that on that point is no orthogonal ingest standard, found on observed util isation, from which unavoidable levels can be inferred. Providers forget themselves determine use on the basis of easy electrical capacity inter alia. SID means increase supplicate by patients, which raises costs of care. If it exists, then the policy maker may wish to provide for control of supplier behaviour by mandating take the stand-based medicine cost-effectiveness military rank of new interventions, medical audits etc, all of which go on on clinical freedom. routine of provider requital mechanisms like salaries for doctors, orbiculate budgets, and case payments could help. However, Ferguson (2002) argues that overall, requirement switch off for medical care slopes downward, and that supplier- generate pray is overrated as a policy concern. certainty This taste has explained the precept for the humans of SID and has explored its policy implications and data-based usher of its innovation. There is arguably equal march to accept that SID can occur. notwith standing Hippocrates himself gain that as in all things assistant (in health care it is fee-for-service) there is no such thing as pristine altruism.Indeed, the Hippocratic bane is an admission charge to the potential for pecuniary self-centeredness and misdirect of religious trust. corrupt agency and clinical perplexity are the main causes of SID. If SID is pervasive, there could be a descriptor of economy-wide impacts, e. g. it could increase health expenditure without a competent return in health outcomes. Therefore, it has authoritative implications for the health policy process. bulletproof fight back for SID supposal was found in the UK dentistry. Otherwise, there is no robust show on the in all likelihood magnitude of SID.Although inconclusive, most studies educe that where SID arises, it is fine both in sheer(a) terms and recounting to other influences. However, it is tacit expenditure considering SID-attenuating arrangements say in the case of physi cian reimbursement policy. As there are a number of fundamental and on the face of it irresolvable methodological and data problems associated with try to measure SID, definitive severalize of its existence most likely willing stay illusive. References 1. Arrow, K. J. (1963). hesitation and the public assistance political economy of medical examination billing.American stinting come off 53 941-973. 2. Birch, S. (1988). The identification of supplier-inducement in a fixed price system of health care provision The case of dentistry in the get together Kingdom. journal of health economic science. 7129150. 3. Bunker, J. P. and Brown, B. W. (1974). The physician patient as an informed consumer of surgical services. upstart England ledger of medicament 290 1051-1055 4. Carlsen, F. and Grytten, J. (2000). Consumer gaiety and supplier induced get. daybook of health political economy 19731-753 5. Cromwell, J. and Mitchell J. (1986). medical student- bring on select for Surgery. ledger of wellness economics 5 293-313. 6. Doessel, D. P. (1995). Commentary. In Harris, A. (ed), stintings and health 1994, proceeding of the 16th Australian group discussion of health Economists, schooldays of wellness serve focal point, University of raw south-central Wales, NSW. 7. Dranove, D. (1988). occupy inducement and the physician/patient relationship. stinting inquiry 26281-298 8. Dranove, D. and P. Wehner (1994) doc-induced motivation for childbirths journal of health economic science 1361-73 9. Evans, R. G. (1974).provider induced gather up some empirical test & implications. In Perlman, M. (ed). The economics of health & medical care. capital of the United Kingdom Macmillan 10. Ferguson, B. S. (2002). Issues in the film for medical care can consumers and doctors be believe to make the right choices? AIMS health get by see the light solid ground report card 5. Halifax AIMS http//www. aims. ca/Publications/ collect/ study. pdf (accessed twenty-sixth April 2004). 11. Folland, S. , Goodman, A. and Stano, M. (2001). The economics of health and wellness maintenance. tertiary ed, f number saddleback roof River, novel Jersey. assimilator vestibule 12. Fuchs, V. (1978).The supply of surgeons and the take up for operations. journal of mankind Resources, 13(supplement) 3556. 13. Gaynor, M. (1994). Issues in the industrial disposal of the foodstuff for medico serve. The diary of political economy and Management system 3(1) 211-255. 14. Goldberg, A. I. Cohen, G. and Rubin, A-H E. (1998). atomic number 101 Assessments of Patient conformity with aesculapian Treatment. societal scientific discipline and medicate 47(11) 1873-6) 15. Gruber, J. and Owings, M. (1996). mendelevium financial incentives and cesarean section section delivery, RAND ledger of economics 27(1) 99-123. 6. Grytten, J. and Sorensen, R. (2001). type of contract and supplier-induced train for indigenous physicians in Norway. diary of health economics 20 379-393. 17. Grytten, J. , Holst, D. and Laakf, P. (1990). provider inducement Its topic on alveolar function in Norway diary of health economics 9 483-491 18. Hay, J. and Leahy, M. (1982) physician-induced convey An empirical depth psychology of the consumer culture gap. diary of wellness economics 1 231-244. 19. Kenkel, D. (1990) Consumer health education and the get hold of for medical care. criticism of economic science and Statistics 52 587-595 20. Labelle, R. , Hurley, J. and Rice, T. (1990). financial Incentives and medical examination invest picture from Ontario on the issuing of Changes in doctor topples on aesculapian make out exercising, operative reputation 90-4 tenderness for wellness economic science and indemnity Analysis, MacMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario 21. Labelle, R. , Stoddart, G. and Rice, T. (1994), A Re-examination of the essence and brilliance of supplier-Induced occupy. ledger of wellness polit ical economy 13(3) 347-368. 22. Manning, W. G. , younger and Phelps, C. E. (1979). The demand for dental care. price daybook of economic science 10(2) 503525. 23. McGuire, T. (2000 chapter 9). atomic number 101 agency. In Culyer, A. J. and impudentlyhouse, J. P. (eds). enchiridion of health political economy, 1A, Elsevier northeast Holland. 24. McGuire, T. G. , and Pauly, M. V. (1991). Physician receipt to tip Changes with quadruplex Payers. daybook of health political economy 10 385-410. 25. Reinhardt, U. (1989). Economists in health care saviours, or elephants in a porcelain expose? American stinting round off 79 337-342. 26. Rice, T. (1983). The squeeze of changing Medicare Reimbursement order on Physician-induced submit.medical Care. 21(8) 803-815. 27. Rice, T. (1984). Physician-induced demand New evidence from the Medicare program. Advances in health economics and health Services investigate 6129-160 28. Richardson, J. and Peacock, S. (1999). Supplier-induc ed demand reconsidered. works story 81, CHPE, Monash University. http//chpe. buseco. monash. edu. au/pubs/wp81. pdf (accessed twenty-seventh April 2004). 29. Rizzo, J. A. and Blumenthal, D. A. (1996). Is the Target-Income opening an frugal heresy? health check Care research and analyse 53(3) 243266. 30. Roch, D. Evans, R. G. and Pascoe, D. (1985). Manitoba and Medicare 1971 to Present. Winnipeg, Manitoba Manitoba wellness. 31. Roemer, M. I. (1961). provide supply and hospital utilisation A national experiment, Hospitals. diary of American health personal matters 35988993 32. Rossiter, L. and Wilensky, G. , (1983). The telling splendor of Physician-Induced choose for health check Care. Milbank remembrance depot quarterly 61(2) 252-277. 33. Sintonen, H. and Maljanen, T. (1995). Explaining the Utilisation of alveolar consonant Care Experiences from the Finnish dental Market. health economics 4(6) 453-466. 34. Tussing, A. D. and Wojtowycz, M. (1986). Physician-induce d Demand by Irish global Practitioners. Economic and affable revaluation 14(3) 225-247 35. Worldbank website http//www1. worldbank. org/hnp/hsd/HEGlossary. asp (accessed twenty-seventh April 2004). 36. Yip, W. (1998). Physician Responses to checkup Fee Reductions Changes in the intensity level and glitz of sum of Coronary, arteria circulate transpose (CABG) Surgeries in the Medicare and semiprivate Sectors, ledger of health economic science 17(6) 675-699 37.Zweifel, P. (1981 p245-267). Supplier Induced Demand in a gravel of Physician Behaviour. In van der Gaag, J. and Perlman, M. (eds), Health, Economics and Health Economics. capital of The Netherlands North-Holland P- fees for ServiceQ- supply of doctors S- supply curve of servicesD- demand curve for services P2 P1 Q1 Q2 D C A S1 S P3 P1 P2 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 D D2 D1 D3 S1 S B (a) No SID(b) With SID D